8. Why This Matter for Human Flourishing
Human flourishing depends on the condition of the soul. The soul, going back to Aristotle and Aquinas, is the integrating center of the person, which unifies the dimension of our being: our thoughts, feelings and emotions, will, body, and social life into one person.
We live well when this inner life is rightly ordered and brought into closer alignment with reality, with what is true, good, and beautiful. That requires more than information. It requires the formation the whole person.
Seen in that light, AI sycophancy is not a minor matter. A system that repeatedly affirms the user can work against the proper ordering of the person.
It can weaken the will by making it harder to consent to reality when reality does not confirm what one wants to believe or keep one from the truths that guide a wise life.
It can shape feelings and emotions by making reassurance seem safer than correction, and by training a person to experience ambiguity, lack of insight, or challenge as threats rather than as occasions for patience and clarity.
It can distort thought by making a preferred interpretation seem more settled than it is.
Feelings & Emotions
Will / Volition
Thoughts
In each case, the person becomes less able to stand quietly before what is true. Seen in that light, AI sycophancy is not a minor matter. A system that repeatedly affirms the user can work against the proper ordering of the person.
All of this matters because spiritual formation does not pause when we use ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. We are always becoming the kind of person who either welcomes reality, goodness, truth or resists them for the sake of feeling in control of comfort and self-protection. If conversational AI trains us to seek confirmation before understanding, it encourages habits of mind, feeling, and choice that work against humility, honesty, and love.
The deepest problem, then, is the gradual formation of a person whose inner life is less able to live in concord reality, which is ultimately in the Way of Jesus.
Contact
I'm always looking for new and exciting opportunities. Let's connect.
123-456-7890